Review: In Their Lives: Great Writers on Great Beatles Songs

In Their Lives

In Their Lives: Great Writers on Great Beatles Songs is an anthology edited by Andrew Blauner. Various writers talk about a single Beatles song. Some are written by other artists and some are writers who you may be familiar with. Chuck Klosterman covers “Helter Skelter,” while Rosanne Cash writes about “No Reply.” Those are just a couple entries in what is a great read on various songs and how they relate to the writers.

In one passage, David Duchovny admits to not even listening to the song again and going off of pure memory. It’s a fun section to read simply because it’s an unorthodox approach. Most writers will try to make sure that they have all of the facts straight before writing about something (although, one could argue that a lot of writers don’t actually do so). However, Duchovny just wants to talk about the song as he remembers it because he doesn’t want to ruin his own memory of it.

I wouldn’t say that the book on the Beatles is revolutionary in any way, but it is an approach to music writing that I personally haven’t come across before. Sure, there are plenty of anthologies out there, but this one allows the writers to approach the songs from a personal aspect rather than an academic one. It’s not pure fact in here, but it’s also how the songs make them feel.

If you’re a fan of the Beatles, there’s a good chance that you feel the same way about some of these songs as the writers do. Overall, I found the book to be an enjoyable read from start to finish. Even with different writers and styles each chapter, there’s a strong sense of general agreement on how great the Beatles were. Be sure to check In Their Lives when you have the chance. You can grab a copy of the book over at Amazon.